Functional and Healthy Features of Conventional and Non-Conventional Sourdoughs

Abstract

Sourdough is a composite ecosystem largely characterized by yeasts and lactic acid bacteria which are the main players in the fermentation process. The specific strains involved are influenced by several factors including the chemical and enzyme composition of the flour and the sourdough production technology. For many decades the scientific community has explored the microbiological, biochemical, technological and nutritional potential of sourdoughs. Traditionally, sourdoughs have been used to improve the organoleptic properties, texture, digestibility, palatability, and safety of bread and other kinds of baked products. Recently, novel sourdough-based biotechnological applications have been proposed to meet the demand of consumers for healthier and more natural food and offer new inputs for the food industry. Many researchers have focused on the beneficial effects of specific enzymatic activities or compounds, such as exopolysaccharides, with both technological and functional roles. Additionally, many studies have explored the ability of sourdough lactic acid bacteria to produce antifungal compounds for use as bio-preservatives. This review provides an overview of the fundamental features of sourdoughs and their exploitation to develop high value-added products with beneficial microorganisms and/or their metabolites, which can positively impact human health.

1. Introduction

Sourdoughs, in all their different types produced worldwide, represent an awesome ecosystem which can offer several opportunities for conventional and non-conventional microbial exploitation to sustain the ecological and nutritional needs of new consumers [1].

Sourdough is a mixture of water and flour that is fermented by cultures of indigenous yeasts and lactic acid bacteria (LAB) [2,3,4]. In addition to these microorganisms, Proteobacteria may also be present, specially at the beginning of fermentation [5,6]. Among them, acetic acid bacteria (AAB), such as those belonging to Gluconobacter sp., Acetobacter sp., and Komagataeibacter sp., allow faster acidification of the dough and influence the volatile attributes of the final product [7,8,9,10]. The indigenous microflora of sourdough is the result of the microbial interaction among microorganisms coming from the flour, the bakery environment, and the vegetable matrices, such as fruits, must, or vinegar, which can be added to the original mixture to accelerate the start-up of fermentation [11].

For many decades the scientific community has explored the microbiological, biochemical, technological, and nutritional potential of sourdoughs and the overall literature, produced in the last 30 years, has been recently reviewed by Arora et al. [12]. What stands out are the novel sourdough-based biotechnological applications proposed, in the last decade, to meet the demand of consumers for healthier and more natural food [13,14].

This review highlights the fundamental features of sourdoughs and their exploitation to develop high value-added products and offer new inputs for the food industry.

In addition to the sourdough technology, this review deals with meaningful studies on the enzymatic activities that have positive effects on human health and the production of compounds with functional properties. Moreover, it reports the potential exploitation of sourdough lactic acid bacteria as bio-preservatives against fungal growth.

2. Sourdough Technology

Based on the technology applied for their production, three main types of sourdough can be distinguished: type I, which is the artisan bakery firm sourdough; type II, referring to industrial liquid sourdoughs; and type III, which indicates industrial dried sourdoughs [15,16] (Figure 1).

Usually, mature type I sourdough contains a mixture of typical yeast and mesophilic LAB strains that characterize sourdough-based products [6]. The stability of the dough depends on the type of flour, the quality and nutritional value of the cereals, the temperature and humidity during processes, and the microbial composition of the inoculum [17,18].

The common yeast species are mainly Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Kazachstania humilis (formerly Candida humilis), Kazachstania exigua, Pichia kudriavzevii, and Torulaspora delbrueckii [19,20]. Moreover, almost 95% of the traditional sourdough population is dominated by heterofermentative LAB alone or in association with homofermentative lactobacilli [15,21]. Lactobacillus sanfranciscensis (currently Fructilactobacillus sanfranciscensis) was most frequently detected in association with yeasts belonging to Kazachstania species, predominantly K. humilis [22,23,24]. Other frequently representative LAB include Lactobacillus plantarum (currently Lactiplantibacillus plantarum), Lactobacillus brevis (currently Levilactobacillus brevis), Leuconostoc spp., and Weissella spp. [1,5,25,26].

To avoid any confusion for the Lactobacillus strains reported in previous studies with the former classification of the genus, the old name of the species will be maintained in the present review; the following link is suggested for the appropriate name conversion: http://lactobacillus.ualberta.ca, accessed on 17 March 2021.

The type I sourdough is prepared according to the traditional method, conducted by daily refreshments, also called “back-slopping”, which keeps it metabolically active. Accordingly, a selection of sourdough microbiota occurs, due to the back-slopping, which is repeated five to ten times [8,27]. These sourdoughs are typical of various traditional Italian sweet baked products, including those that are commercialized and consumed during holiday seasons, such as Panettone and Colomba [3,18,28].

Type II and III sourdoughs (the latter is made by dehydrating the stabilized form of type II sourdough) were developed for industries with the aim of providing a more standardized process [6]. Both are made with selected cultures added at a ratio of 100:1 (LAB to yeasts) to obtain specific features of the baked products and inhibit the growth of unwanted microbiota [8].

The selection of microbial strains useful as starter cultures is fundamental for sourdough industries and relies on various metabolic traits that have both technological and functional interest [29,30]. In this context, qualified microbial culture collections, constitute a fundamental cornerstone for the investigation of sourdoughs’ microbiota to select strains with desired features [31].

Among LAB, the selection of potential starters is generally made within the Lactobacillaceae and the most often used are acid-tolerant strains such as L. amylovorus, L. panis, L. pontis, and L. reuteri [27,32,33].

Different non-lactobacillus strains have also been tested as suitable starters because of the positive effect of their compounds on the sourdough flavor, which can open new prospects in the sourdough industries. As reported by Montemurro et al. [34], Pediococcus pentosaceus OA1 and S3N3 and Leuconostoc citreum PRO17 were selected on the basis of optimal acidification and growth performance, as well as the intense proteolytic activity in whole wheat flour doughs.

Recently, AAB have also been considered useful starters for the production of desired metabolites [7]. Accordingly, Acetobacter pasteurianus IMDO 386B and Gluconobacter oxydans IMDO A845 strains were tested for type II sourdough production processes and the latter, in particular, had an attractive impact on the production of volatile organic compounds [7].

3. Nutritional and Functional Features of Sourdough

Sourdough fermentation is certainly the most conventional and efficient tool for guaranteeing rheology, sensory, hygiene and shelf-life features [14]. Additionally, it has the potentiality to enhance the nutritional and functional features of wheat flours [35,36,37,38].

The positive effects provided by sourdough technology can be summarized as:

• preservation of food through acetic acid, lactic acid, alcoholic, and alkaline fermentations;
• food enrichment with compounds that originate either from biochemical reactions (e.g., essential amino acids, proteins and essential fatty acids), or biosynthesis (e.g., vitamins);
• development of aromas, flavors and textures in food substrates;
• detoxification during food fermentation processing.

Moreover, it has been reported that sourdough fermentation can lower glycemic index, increase mineral bioavailability, reduce gluten content and reduce starch digestibility, mainly through the organic acids production and other complementary mechanisms [12,39]. The main outcomes of sourdough fermentation are shown in Figure 2.

In recent years the development of high-quality gluten-free (GF) products has become an important socio-economic issue and a new approach in this framework is represented by the application of sourdough fermentation [40].

Common products for celiacs available on the market are often characterized by poor palatability and lack of minerals and fibers [41]. Moreover, they usually have a low amount of health promoting nutrients, such as B vitamins groups, which are essential in the human diet; for instance, folate (B11) is involved in fundamental metabolic reaction, biosynthesis of nucleotides, building blocks of DNA and RNA and prevent neural tube defects in newborns [40]. Consequently, fermentation with LAB and yeasts can be considered an effective methodology in food production suitable for the development of new kinds of GF products with nutraceutical and health-promoting features [42]. Applying microbial selected cultures to suitable raw materials, the fermentation process can be modulated, also enhancing the content of bioactive metabolites and other compounds, such as glutathione, which exert an antioxidant activity [22,43,44,45].

Moreover, the sourdough fermentation can be useful in preserving some good sensory characteristics, such as products’ structure and/or softness maintenance during storage, which are usually compromised by the lack of gluten [46,47]. Therefore, the selection of specific sourdough cultures has been considered as a new tool for GF food processing [14,48,49].

Various ecological studies have provided useful information on the presence of competitive LAB and yeasts strains, which can be used as candidates for starter development [50]. In rice, maize, teff, and amaranth sourdough, for instance, is frequently used to isolate microorganisms such as: L. fermentum, L. plantarum, and L. paralimentarius [51]. Above them, strains of L. helveticus, L. pontis, and S. cerevisiae are most competitive in different kind of cereals, pseudo-cereals, and cassava sourdoughs [10,52]. Positive cooking performance, obtained with the use of sourdough in GF products, in terms of definite volume, flavor, texture and mouthfeel encourages further studies and the development of an industrial production [40].

In particular, the flavor profile of the product can be greatly affected by the use of sourdough, depending on type of starter cultures, fermentation conditions, baking conditions and raw material. Recently, researchers have proposed the use of sourdough-fermented ingredients to reach new sensorial profile and enhance nutritional value in pasta [13]. The use of sourdough for pasta fortification has been explored under several aspects and has also been applied with success to mixed flour composed by pseudo-cereals and legumes, allowing an increasing of γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) levels [53]. GABA is a non-protein amino acid with several physiological functions, such as induction of hypotension and prevention of diabetes as well as diuretic and tranquilizer effects [54,55]. A systematic review on its production from LAB has been recently reported by Cui et al. [56]. The use of non-conventional flours to obtain food products characterized by peculiar flavor, abundance of proteins with high nutritional value, dietary fibers, polyphenols, and minerals, represent an attractive feature to be explored by food industries for new applications of sourdough microbiota [26,42].

3.1. Enzymatic Activities with Beneficial Effects on Human Health

It is known that cereal grains are significant sources of minerals such as magnesium, potassium, iron and zinc. However, they also contain phytic acid or myo-inositol hexakiphosphate (IP6) (1–4% of dry weight) [57,58]. This compound is an anti-nutritional factor for humans and animals, in fact, the central hexaphosphate ring is highly charged due to six anionic groups and acts as a chelator of dietary minerals reducing their bioavailability [59,60]. Sourdough fermentation, owing to the pH reduction, provides suitable conditions for cereal endogenous phytase activities [36,61]. The phytases that take part in the process are also exogenous and they are produced by a large number of microorganisms among which are sourdough yeasts and LAB. Their activity reduces to less than a half the phytate content of whole wheat bread and allows to increase bioavailability of minerals, free amino acids, and proteins. A recent screening on 152 LAB, isolated from cereal-based substrates, revealed a widespread capacity of the isolates (95%) for degrading phytic acid. Among the isolates, strains L. brevis LD65 and L. plantarum PB241, showed the highest phytase activity; on the contrary, Weissella confusa strains showed low or no phytase activity [62].

Allergies, intolerances, and sensitive individuals are also positively influenced by the LAB present in the sourdough, as they can show specific enzymatic activities toward gluten proteins. The proteolytic activity carried out by endogenous and exogenous proteases during the fermentation process with sourdough seems to lead to a complete hydrolysis of gluten, meeting the needs of individuals affected by celiac disease [32].

3.2. Effects of Organic Acids

Most of the valuable properties attributed to sourdough are due to the acidification activity, due to LAB and AAB. In fact, during fermentation, several organic acids, e.g., lactic, acetic, citric, pyruvic and succinic acid are produced. Among them, lactic and acetic acid are the most important as they can greatly affect the aroma profile and rheological properties of sourdoughs [58]. Their production depends upon several factor including flour type, starter used, metabolic activity, technological performance, and acidification properties of the wheat sourdoughs [63]. Organic acids produced during sourdough fermentation can have preservative and antimicrobial effects, improving storability and safety [64], as well as have positive health effects. For instance, acetic acid, propionic and lactic acid have the capacity of lowering the insulin response [65]. The mechanisms of these acids seem to vary; lactic acid acts to lower the rate of starch digestion in bread while propionic and acetic acids seem to extend the gastric emptying rate [66].

As suggested by the work of Östman et al. [67], lactic acid, in particular, is designed to lower blood sugar and promote an interaction between starch and gluten favoring the reduction of starch bioavailability.

4. Exopolysaccharides

Exopolysaccharides (EPS) are biopolymers of high molecular weight produced by several microorganisms, such as LAB, AAB and microalgae [68,69,70].

Based on the chemical composition and biosynthesis mechanisms, microbial EPS are classified into two distinct groups: (1) homopolysaccharides (HoPS), such as glucans and fructans, (2) heteropolysaccharides (HePS), e.g., gellan and xanthan [71]. Among the HoPS, dextran, levan, and cellulose are mostl important in the food industry for their significant features [71,72]. In particular, EPS-producing LAB are attractive for application in bakery products thanks to their ability as viscosifiers, texturizers, emulsifiers, and syneresis-lowering agents [62,70]. In addition to polysaccharides naturally occurring in cereal grains flour and dough, microbial EPS from sucrose can be produced in sourdough through the activity of glycosyltransferases [73]. It has been reported that fructan from L. sanfransiscensis can positively affect the dough rheology and bread texture more than the external addition of the same polysaccharides [74]. Furthermore, it has been shown that dextran produced in situ can improve texture and cover unpleasant flavors of wholegrain bread suggesting microbial EPS as a possible substitute of sweeteners [75].

Sourdough technology using EPS-producing LAB strains seem to be a valid solution to improve GF baked products [70]. For instance, microbial EPS can replace hydrocolloids, which are fundamental components in GF products to get acceptable quality levels in terms of texture, volume, and shelf life [76].

Other evidence has been recently reported by Franco et al. [77], who described EPS, produced by Pediococcus, Leuconostoc, and Weisella strains in quinoa sourdough, able to improve the organoleptic and rheological attributes in GF-free doughs. Consequently, the development of EPS-producing starter cultures for different types of flour sourdoughs has been receiving a growing-interest in the last years, also due to the potential health benefits associated with EPS themselves as prebiotics, which can be exploited to make added-value functional products [78]

5. Bioactive Compounds

Cereals contain different phytochemicals, such as phenolic acids, phytosterols, alkylresorcinols, tocols, lignans, and folate [79]. Among other processing conditions, e.g., milling and malting, the sourdough fermentation is the one that most affects the levels and bioavailability of phytochemicals and increases the level of extractable phenolic compounds [14,80]. Furthermore, bioactive compounds are synthesized during fermentation, while other components involved in grain-related digestion problems or pathologies, such as gluten sensitivity or gastrointestinal syndromes, are reduced [81].

As reported by Katina et al. [82], folate and other free phenolic acids increased up to seven and ten times in germinated rye during sourdough fermentation. Moreover, comparing the capability of different yeasts and LAB to affect the folate content in a rye sourdough, it was demonstrated that the synthesis of folate by bacteria was minimal, while the yeasts were able to increase its content over three-fold in the best case [83].

Regarding the vitamin E, tocopherol and tocotrienol, a reduction during the sourdough preparation and dough making has been reported, probably due to the sensitivity of the compounds to the air [14].

Several authors have stated LAB as the microbes most suitable in bioactive peptides enrichment [55,84]. According to Rizzello et al. [49,55], selected sourdough lactobacilli with specific proteinase and peptidase activities toward cereal proteins, were effectively used for releasing Angiotensin I-Converting Enzyme (ACE)-inhibitory peptides during a long-time sourdough fermentation. These peptides are of great interest for functional foods as they may be used for avoiding hypertension and for other therapeutic purposes [55]. Another study showed that sourdough LAB can increase the concentration of lunasin, a cancer-preventing peptide, during fermentation of various flours, including those of wheat, barley, amaranth, soybean, or rye [85]. Specifically, L. curvatus SAL33 and L. brevis AM7 strains used as sourdough starters were able to synthesize this compound, increasing its concentration up to 2–4 times during fermentation.

6. Antifungal Compounds

One of the big issues in the bakery product industries are moulds – the primary cause of spoilage, off-flavors and potentially producing harmful secondary metabolites commonly called mycotoxins. Aflatoxins are the most common hazardous mycotoxins, causing both chronic and acute toxicity to humans and cattle. Usually, chemical preservatives are successfully used against fungal growth, however, the exploitation of sourdough LAB, as bio-preservatives, has gained great interest among researchers and industries driven by the growing demand for clean label products in which chemically derived ingredients are replaced by natural alternatives [86].

Generally, LAB can be considered protective microorganisms not only for their production of lactate and acetate, which act as effective preservatives, but also for releasing other active compounds during fermentation. Indeed, a synergistic effect between pH and antifungal metabolites seems to be responsible of the LAB protective activity [87,88]. The majority of antifungal substances produced from LAB include organic acids, hydrogen peroxide, reuterin, proteinaceous and phenolic compounds, hydroxyl fatty acids, and other low-molecular-weight compounds [89,90].

Several studies have investigated the ability of sourdough LAB to prevent moulding events on leavened goods; some examples referred to specific strains are reported in

Table 1. Some lactic acid bacteria strains from sourdoughs tested for their antifungal activity.

LAB Strains	Compounds with Antifungal Activity	Fungal Target Tested	Reference
L. sanfrancisencis CB1	Acetic, caproic, formic, propionic, butyric and n-valeric acids	Fusarium graminearum 623	[91]
L. plantarum 21B	Phenyllactic acid and 4-hydroxyphenyllactic acid	Aspergillus niger FTDC3227	[92]
L. plantarum CRL 778 L. reuteri CRL 1100 L. brevis CRL 772 L. brevis CRL 796	Lactic, acetic, and phenyllactic acids	Penicillium sp. Aspergillus niger Fusarium graminearum	[93]
L. buchneri FUA 3525 L. diolovorans DSM 14421	Propionate and acetate	Aspergillum clavatus Cladisporium spp. Mortierella spp. Penicillium Roquefort	[94]
L. rossiae LD108, L. paralimentarius PB127	Lactic acid, acetic acid, phenyllactic acid and diacetyl	Aspergillum japonicus	[95]
L. amylovorus DSM 19280	Lactic acid, acetic acid, 3-phenylpropanoic acid, p-coumaric, (E)-2-methylcinnamic acid, 3-phenyllactic acid and cyclic dipetides	Fusarium culmorum FST 4.05 Aspergillus niger FST4.21 Penicillium expansum FST 4.22 Penicillium roqueforti FST 4.11	[96,97]
L. paracasei subsp. tolerans L17	Cell-wall binding and enzyme-mediated degradation	Fusarium proliferatum M 5991 Fusarium proliferatum M 5689 Fusarium graminearum R 4053	[98,99]

. A comprehensive review on the ability of LAB to serve as antifungal and anti-mycotoxigenic agents have been recently provided by Sadiq et al. [86].

7. Sourdough Effectiveness on Rheology, Shelf-Life and Safety

The impact of sourdough on properties and rheological behavior of dough has been widely investigated. Generally, changes may be attributed to several intrinsically related factors, including variations in the rate or amount of acid produced [100].

For instance, a low proteolytic degradation of wheat proteins affects the physical properties of gluten and, thus, influences the firmness and staling of the final baked product [101]. The specific proteolytic activity of sourdough microorganisms also has a great impact [102]. As proved by Clarke et al. [103], the use of sourdough, prepared either from a single strain or a mixed strain starter culture, significantly influenced the rheological properties of wheat flour dough; sourdough prepared with starter cultures increased the softening level of the dough.

Regarding gas production in sourdoughs, Hammes and Gänzle [27] proved that the contribution of yeasts and LAB changes according to the type of starter and the dough technology. This aspect is particularly important in the GF products where the lack of the viscoelastic gluten system is responsible for low expansion and gas retention during leavening [104]. The efficiency of the addition of sourdough on GF bread quality was demonstrated in various formulations made of a different kind of flour by Picozzi et al. [105], which used a Type I GF-sourdough with a stable association between L. sanfranciscensis and C. humilis. The positive effects of sourdough on rheology and texture, in terms of volume and softness, led to an extended shelf-life of the baked products. This aspect is certainly of great interest for the bakery industry which has recently reevaluated the traditional sourdough fermentation to contrast the short shelf-life of baked products, like bread, mainly caused by spoilage microorganisms.

In fact, sourdough can act as a natural preservative able to replace the use of chemical preservatives. Above the antifungal activity described in the previous section, antibacterial activity has been also scientifically proven [106]. Bread quality and safety can be affected by spore-forming bacteria, such as Bacillus subtilis, which mainly occur on the outer parts of grains, and consequently can contaminate also the other ingredients and/or bakery environment [107,108]. The antibacterial effect of sourdough is generally attributed to the synergistic activity of several compounds produced by yeasts and LAB, which includes the synthesis of organic acids, EPS, antimicrobial compounds, bioactive peptides as well as the conversion of phenolic compounds and lipids [106,109,110].

Therefore, sourdough technology combined with the use of high-quality flours represent a tool for improving both organoleptic and healthy features of the baked goods. Optimized sourdoughs obtained with non-conventional flours are the new input for food companies which want to satisfy the needs of consumers affected by allergies and food intolerance.

Legumes and pseudocereals, such as amaranth and quinoa, which have very different chemical composition and technological properties compared to wheat, can be a valid alternative useful for the development of new food products included in different kinds of bread, pasta, or snacks [13]. Regarding the allergies issue, the European Regulation No. 1169/2011 have been adopted with the aim to improve the labeling of foods with the clear indication of ingredients and nutritional values. Accurate food labeling can, in fact, allow consumers suffering from allergies or intolerances of knowing the specific ingredients present in food products and help them to make healthier choices [111].

8. Conclusions

Sourdough fermentation has emerged in human history and since then, it has been empirically used for the improvement of the organoleptic properties, texture, digestibility, palatability, and safety of different food matrices. Nowadays, sourdough fermentation is widely employed to enrich food with beneficial microorganisms and/or their metabolites, which positively impact human health. This result can be achieved either through the exploitation of the wild microbiota naturally associated to raw materials or as the result of the inoculation of selected starters.

The wide and successful use of sourdough, maintained over time for its peculiar and unique features, confirms this ancient biotechnology as an effective answer to the modern world demand for natural, healthy, and eco-friendly food.